Brother Bruno's


Doing Business the Right Way

Doing Business the Right Way

Doing Business the Right Way

 Brother Bruno’s is Middletown is unaffiliated with any other Brother Bruno’s. Our Middletown location is our last & final pizzeria under original ownership. Our 1980’s recipes & style of pizza making has not & will not change since our day one opening in 1983. Our main goal is to always achieve a high level of customer satisfaction with the services and products that we are so very proud to provide. This simple approach  has effectively fueled our growth since we opened our doors in 1983.  We would like all our customers to leave our place happy all the time, every time.  We're thrilled you've decided to visit us- please browse our site to discover what we're all about. 


What Cheese do you use?

Doing Business the Right Way

Doing Business the Right Way

At Brother Bruno's Pizza in Middletown we only use Grande Mozzarella cheese. It’s  shredded daily from the block, not pulled out from a plastic industrial bag. For us, the choice is easy... & it ain't pre-shredded. We ONLY use premium mozzarella cheese from the Grande Cheese Company in Wisconsin. It is the best cheese money can buy.  We order ours in seven pound blocks directly from the company & shred them at our shop daily so you get the absolute freshest ingredients possible. 


What Pizzas do you offer?

Doing Business the Right Way

What Pizzas do you offer?

We offer two types of pizza. Neapolitan (thin & round) & Sicilian (thick & square.)  We also offer a Grandma style Pizza that takes a good 35 minutes to make, as the dough needs a 10 minute rest period after the dough is stretched out.  It's a thin crust pizza with a fresh garlic & oil base, fresh plum tomato, grande cheese & fresh basil to finish on top. Just like grandma used to make. 


Follow us on Instagram & Like us on Facebook for new updates @ Brother Brunos Pizza


Italian Combo

Italian Combo is a big fan favorite. Although all our of subs are praised in Middletown , the Italian combo outs wins the others. Can't go wrong with Italian Combo Works & fully loaded!


Local Guide

"We took our little league team here after practice. They were very accommodating to our large group. Before we got there, at least 3 of the parents said this is the best pizza in Middletown. I think they're right! Will definitely go back."

Come grab a slice!

Special Requests?

Do you have dietary concerns? Questions about catering an upcoming event? Drop us a line, and we'll get back to you soon!

Brother Bruno’s Pizza

125 Dolson Avenue, Middletown, New York 10940, United State



Open today

11:00 am – 11:00 pm

Monday - Thursday  11am - 10pm

Friday & Saturday: 11am - 11pm

Sunday: 12pm-10pm

We are closed on all major Holidays

Contact Us